Share this page

Dating back to 1846 when Sag Harbor was a whaling town, The American Hotel still has the charm reminiscent of those days Small and initimate, the guest rooms are formal and decorated with antiques. The award winning restaurant's inventive "New French" cuisine is recognized as possibly the finest dining on the Island. The wine list is second to none.

  • Wifi
  • Restaurant Onsite
  • Pets Allowed
  • Property Size N/A
  • Conference Facility
  • Kids Allowed
  • Nearby City Sag Harbor
  • Nearby Water N/A
  • Open Dates All Year

Nearest Airports

  • Elizabeth Field (FID) / 22.5 miles
  • Groton New London Airport (GON) / 26.7 miles
  • Tweed New Haven Airport (HVN) / 35.8 miles

* Not all airports listed here may be open to public use, or service commercial flights

Additional Information

Languages Spoken
  • English
Main Street Sag Harbor, New York 11963 United States  
Rates From


Phone Number


Send an



No problem! Select the type of inquiry you'd like to send, enter your comments, and we'll make sure the property gets it.

By clicking 'Submit' you are agreeing to our Terms of Service

Vacation Request Successfully submitted. Thank You!

Lodging in or near Sag Harbor

9.2 miles away

14.7 miles away

19.8 miles away

20.2 miles away

56 Reviews

21.1 miles away

Very Good
201 Reviews