An unrivaled beauty queen, The Gardens Hotel is the reigning favorite.
The Gardens Hotel
Silver Palms Inn
Mermaid & The Alligator
Top 10 Key West Luxury Resorts
Our No. 8 pick was named prettiest hotel in Key West by the New York Times. If you ask us, we think Key West luxury like this deserves to be experienced with the prettiest, handsomest and downright luckiest special someone in your life!