Resorts & LodgesVacation RentalsTravel Guides
List Your Property

End Your Quest for Adventure at Amara Cay Resort!

In the Caribbean dream of Islamadora, Florida, Amara Cay Resort sits where saltwater wilderness meets pampered paradise! Islamadora tides wash away your sand-impressed footprints and puts an end to your quest. Erase your stress and find paradise in the tropical pastels of seaside suites and thatched roof Tiki-hut and coconut palm-lined pools. Outside the temperature-controlled poolside, this Sport Fishing Capital of the World provides an endless supply of diving, snorkeling, wave-running, sea kayaking, and more aquatic adventures in the warmth of its clear Keys waters. Find rentals, guides, and gifts galore in Seamonkey's Dive Shop, book a tour with a charter partner Offshore Fishing, and rediscover your inner beach bum at Amara Cay Resort beach. A mainland favorite meets the island appeal of Islamorada in this tropical twist special Amara Cay Resort!

  • Wifi
  • Restaurant Onsite
  • Pets Allowed
  • Property Size 79 units
  • Conference Facility
  • Kids Allowed
  • Nearby City Islamadora
  • Nearby Water Atlantic Ocean
  • Open Dates All Year


Soak in the island sun on a white sandy North Atlantic beach beside the waters that run with the shallow Caribbean and the glittering Gulf at the Amara Cay Resort. Coconut Palm Trees and Tiki thatched umbrellas shade your Adirondack chair before the breathtaking backdrop of this oceanfront hotel. Whether you spend a day building sandcastles with the kids or exploring the depths of the waters, you're sure to experience a beach vacation unlike any other!


You'll feel like you've found your own private island at Amara Cay Resort in the historic vacation headquarters of the Florida Keys. Simplify the luxury retreat and head for spectacular hotel amenities, marina & watersports adventures, and tropical pool and hot tub of the Amara Cay signature Islamadora resort. Gift shop, playground, room service, cribs, high chairs, and on-site dining add convenience to luxury and welcome you to your new home away from home in the fishing and diving capital of the world!


Experience the enchantment of a warm tropical paradise in Florida Keys' Islamadora! This village of islands beckons to fishermen, honeymooners, nature lovers, and more. Fine ecological treasures and breathtaking adventure between the backcountry waters of the Sport Fishing Capital of the World and Everglades National Park, North America's only coral barrier reef!


Dip your lure into the alluring corner where the Gulf of Mexico, Atlantic Ocean, and the Caribbean meet. This favorite fishing spot is understandably dubbed the "fishing capital of the world!" Get a back country guide and go deep-sea fishing with charter partners Back Country Fishing or Off Shore Fishing for a day of real ocean adventure!


Where all suites face the sea, find a real romantic retreat in the island paradise of Florida Keys' Amara Cay Resort. Private beach meets world class sportsfishing, snorkeling, and diving between the salty sea and Everglades National Park wilderness on the water.


Make your honeymoon an unforgettable adventure together in the wide waters of the warm Atlantic Ocean from Amara Cay Resort. Tropical sea-side suites, TikiBar, and more compliment well with nearby ocean excursions. Swim with the dolphins at the Theater of the Sea or take an eco-tour to explore coral formations, tropical fish, dolphin pods, manatees, crocodiles, and roseate spoonbills. Kayaking adventures await you in the remote Indian Key Historic State Park and Lignumvitae Key Botanical State Park, all island utopias just awaiting discovery.

Cabins, Cottages, and Chalets

Pretty pastels and Coconut Palm carved wood deck your oceanfront suite in distinctive island style at Amara Cay Resort. Cloud Nine beds, pampering massage amenities, private balconies, and more add a bit of romance to your tropical escape suite. Queen, King, and Double bed suites are all oceanfront or shoreline view and offer the comforts, amenities, and service you'd expect in a private island paradise.


Discover an underwater world at dozens of dive and snorkel sites for all experience levels. This Islamadora hotel offers full dive certifications, refresher courses, and check out dives in the clear Keys waters. Or find your own way atop the sea on a sea kayak, wave runner, or Snor-Ski tour! Your supplies are stocked at onsite Seamonkey's Dive Shop.


Make a little holiday magic in the island treasure Amara Cay Resort. Oceanic splendor lends its natural beauty to dreamy blue waters ripe with giant sports fish, Everglades National Park saltwater wilderness, and the seaside reefs, beaches, and wildlife that make this Florida Keys island village hotel a host for the best adventures.


Islamadora consists of a village of islands that form a beautiful branch of the Florida Keys. When you stay at Amara Cay Resort, you're in the best spot to experience the refreshing tropical air, the white sand shores, and the clear blue waters. Enjoy all this Sports Fishing and Diving Capital of the World has to offer on an aquatic adventure of your own!

Additional Information

  • Cribs
  • Fitness Center
  • Gift Shop
  • Swimming Pool
  • Beach
  • Boating & Watercraft
  • Boat Docks
  • Kayaking
  • Play Ground
  • Beach
  • Bird Watching
  • Hiking
  • Wildlife & Nature
  • Saltwater Fishing
  • Scuba Diving
Room Amenities
  • Alarm Clock
  • Balcony
  • Coffee Maker
  • Deck
  • Hair Dryer
  • Hot Tub
  • Iron/Ironing Board
  • Kitchenette
  • Live Entertainment
  • Photography
  • Shopping
  • Sightseeing
  • Swimming
  • Free Parking
  • ATM
  • Business Center
  • Fishing Guides
  • Laundry Facilities
  • Room Service
  • Fitness Programs
Languages Spoken
  • English

Nearest Airports

  • Miami International Airport (MIA) / 65.8 miles
  • Key West International Airport (EYW) / 73.3 miles
  • Fort Lauderdale Hollywood International Airport (FLL) / 86.9 miles

* Not all airports listed here may be open to public use, or service commercial flights

Message this property

By clicking 'Submit' you are agreeing to our Terms of Service

Vacation Request Successfully submitted. Thank You!

Lodging in or near Islamorada

2.4 miles away

2.8 miles away

3.6 miles away

4.5 miles away

17.3 miles away

22.6 miles away